If you’re in a hurry and just want the direct answer — Five Guys offers bigger burgers than Shake Shack. A regular burger at Five Guys comes with two patties by default, each around 3.3–3.7 ounces, giving you a total of over 6.6 ounces of beef. In contrast, a single ShackBurger at Shake Shack contains just one 4-ounce patty, and even their double burger is smaller than the Five Guys’ standard offering.
So if burger size is your top concern, Five Guys wins — but there’s more to explore, including taste, quality, and popularity. Keep reading for a full explaination!
Detailed Comparison: Shake Shack vs Five Guys
Who Is This Comparison For?
- People looking for value for money in burger size
- Burger lovers wanting to try the biggest fast food burgers
- Those deciding between Shake Shack or Five Guys for their next cheat meal
- Foodies interested in both taste and quantity
Burger Size Showdown: Shake Shack vs Five Guys
Patty Weight Comparison
| Restaurant | Single Patty Weight | Standard Burger Configuration | Total Patty Weight |
|---|---|---|---|
| Five Guys | 3.3–3.7 oz | 2 patties per burger | 6.6–7.4 oz |
| Shake Shack | 4 oz | 1 patty per burger (double optional) | 4–8 oz |
Serving Size
- Five Guys:
- Standard burgers are served with two patties automatically.
- More generous with toppings, especially if you add all 15 free ones.
- Overall burger feels thicker and heavier.
- Shake Shack:
- Default ShackBurger comes with one patty.
- You can order a double, but still slightly smaller than Five Guys.
- The bun-to-patty ratio is tighter, giving it a cleaner look but less bulk.
Verdict on Size:
Five Guys has a significantly bigger burger, both in terms of beef and volume. If you want to feel full and hold a massive burger, Five Guys is the clear winner.
Which Burger Tastes Better?
Now let’s talk flavor. Because bigger isn’t always better — sometimes, taste wins.
Shake Shack: The Flavor King?
- Uses premium Angus beef.
- Famous for their ShackSauce — a creamy, tangy, unique spread.
- The burger has a smash-style crisp with a soft inside.
- Martin’s potato rolls add a sweet, soft bun texture.
Five Guys: The Fresh Custom Beast
- Fresh, never frozen ground beef.
- No set toppings — you customize everything, from jalapeños to grilled mushrooms.
- Patties are juicy, thicker, and have a grilled flavor.
- Fries (cooked in peanut oil) are often mentioned with the burgers because of portion size.
Taste Verdict:
- Shake Shack has a more refined, gourmet taste.
- Five Guys is meatier, juicier, and gives you freedom to build your dream burger.
So, if you’re after flavor precision, go with Shake Shack. If you want robust grill taste and customization, pick Five Guys.
You Should Read this : What oil does shake shack use?
Popularity: Which Brand Do People Prefer?
Market Presence
| Brand | Global Locations | Known For |
|---|---|---|
| Shake Shack | 470+ | Gourmet fast-food, flavor |
| Five Guys | 1,700+ | Size, freshness, simplicity |
- Five Guys is more widespread, especially in the U.S. and Europe.
- Shake Shack is smaller but growing rapidly in urban areas and malls.
Why People Love Them:
Five Guys:
- No freezer – everything is fresh.
- Big servings.
- Unlimited topping combos.
Shake Shack:
- Trendy and Instagram-worthy.
- Quality over quantity.
- Strong brand appeal among younger crowds.
Verdict:
- In terms of sheer popularity and availability, Five Guys wins.
- For urban cool factor and quality buzz, Shake Shack takes it.
Summary Table: Shake Shack vs Five Guys
| Feature | Shake Shack | Five Guys |
|---|---|---|
| Burger Size | Smaller (4–8 oz) | Bigger (6.6–7.4 oz) |
| Taste | Gourmet, rich, unique | Juicy, grilled, custom |
| Customization | Limited (preset) | Full topping control |
| Value for Money | Good | Excellent |
| Popularity | Urban & trendy | Widely accessible |
Extra Insights
Which Burger Is More Filling?
- Five Guys. The extra patty and custom toppings give a heavier, more satisfying meal.
Which Is More Expensive?
- Both are premium priced, but Five Guys often costs more because it includes double patties.
Sides Matter Too
- Five Guys’ fries are legendary — extra-large portions, even in a small cup.
- Shake Shack offers crinkle-cut fries, great but not as generously portioned.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which restaurant has bigger size burger | Shake Shack or Five Guys?
Five Guys. Their burgers include two patties by default, making them significantly larger than Shake Shack’s single patty burgers.
Which burger is more flavorful?
Shake Shack is more gourmet, while Five Guys offers a juicier and more grilled flavor with full customization.
Is Shake Shack more expensive than Five Guys?
Not always. Shake Shack’s double burgers may cost more, but Five Guys includes more meat per burger.
Which is better for cheat meals?
Five Guys — it’s bigger, heavier, and more indulgent.
Are toppings free at Five Guys?
Yes, you can choose from over 15 toppings at no extra cost.
Final Decision: Who Wins the Burger War?
- If your priority is SIZE and FILLING:
🏆 Five Guys wins hands down with its double patty default. - If your priority is TASTE and QUALITY:
🍔 Shake Shack takes the crown with its gourmet-style build and sauces. - For overall value:
🥇 Five Guys offers more food per dollar spent.
Conclusion: Which Restaurant Has Bigger Size Burger?
If you came looking for the biggest burger, the winner is simple: Five Guys. You’ll get more meat, more toppings, and a more filling experience. But don’t count out Shake Shack — its refined taste and urban appeal make it a favorite for those who crave quality over quantity.
